About this blog

Untypical Boro is a lively topical blog by the Evening Gazette's award winning football columnist Anthony Vickers that aims to get behind the headlines to flesh out the stories that Boro fans are talking about.

Incisive, provocative and well informed it seeks to engage with articulate supporters and give them a platform to help set the agenda on the issues that matter.

Recent comments

Recent Posts

Sponsored links

Archives

Links

Advertiser

Sponsored links


Franck Q Very Much

Posted by on July 21, 2006 2:20 PM | 

SACRE bleu! Franck Queudrue is on the verge of making a diagonal move to Fulham - or possibly Charlton - leaving a vacancy for a Riverside cult hero who can really connect with the crowd. And leaving an enigma.

The pin-up Frenchman will be missed, not least by the East Stand honeys who swooned as he cut a gallic dash on the pitch, because he added colour and passion to what at times in recent years has been a dull squad.

Red, that was a colour he added. His popularity earned him a leeway that other rash defenders who dived in to tackles in dangerous positions that either conceded a free-kick or let the opponent race through clear on goal would never have got. Five red cards - a record shared with Ugo's tally over a far longer spell - and countless yellows peppered his five years at the Riverside... but the serial suspendee was forgiven everything.


It seems at any one time there must be some players who are cruelly damned as donkeys no matter how well they play and some who are elevated to heroic status even if they are inconsistent or limited. And some who grip the popular imagination and have a real bandwagon of widespread vocal support behind them.

The selection for this appears to be some mystical process where favourites emerge in a flurry of stirring activity - crunching tackles, putting your head in where the boots are flying, fisticuffs, scoring against Sunderland on your debut - then are cemented in the consensus by a selective view of every game that follows, exaggerating the good but ignoring the bad in an individual's performance.

Franck is no Juninho. There is no tunnel visioned cult behind him ready to declare a fatwa against any non-believers who dare criticise. But there is a considerable group who were willing to forgive him almost any mistake because he "showed passion" and who are struggling to accept his departure. There is even misguided talk of a Craig Hignett style "don't go" petition. It is doomed: he wants to go.

But there is more to Franck than just being a player. He has also become a symbol in recent years for the struggle against McClaren. He was often made the scapegoat for defeats (often, it must be said, with some justification) and was sometimes dropped on the flimsiest of excuses. Last season he found himself behind new boy Emmanuel Pogotetz in the pecking order, a simmering player who made the Frenchmen look ice cool and meek in the tackle.

His case was taken up eagerly by the Macophobes as a stick to beat the boss with, just as Mark Crossley had become a weapon before him. It appeared perversely self-defeating to have a player on the bench who was by general consent better than the man in his position on the pitch. It proved the boss didn't know what he was doing. And it fuelled a flurry of rumours of bust-ups and worse.

Certainly there were things happing behind the scenes. In January with McClaren desperate to strength the fraying squad Franck was one of the few assets that would raise anything more than peanuts and it appeared he was being offered to other clubs as part of the attempted wheeler-dealing. Luckily for McClaren it did not come off as Queudrue's exit in January would have thrown petrol on the flames of anger then licking the Riverside - but it may well have left the left-back nursing a grievence and sense of betrayal and made up his mind to leave.

It would be ironic if Franck's departure was part of Steve McClaren's legacy because he should be rated as one of his best signings. Arriving on a loan he signed for £2.5m and gave the club four good years (and one indifferent) and some good memories. Queudrue has been at the heart of things as Boro have carved out a golden era. He played in the FA Cup semi-finals in McClaren's first and last seasons (and wore tres chic head bandages in both), he was in the historic team of heroes who lifted silver in Cardiff and he played a key part in both UEFA Cup campaigns and was in the team at Eindhoven.

He has made a massive contribution to the Boro story and deserves praise for that. Thanks Franck.



Comments (9)

John Powls wrote...

Vic

And so say all of us. Lots of other rumours abound too - about off the field issues. Whatever the issues it's no use trying to hang on to someone determined to go.

Equally it's no use anyone trying to claim Pogo can fill the vacancy either. Leave aside the red mist moments - he is slow, lacks any positional sense and never seems to have learned the particular skills of left-back play. No better than a utility understudy across the back.

I don't see Arca as a Prem full back either, unless we're going to play 3-5-2 with him at wing back. If he's going to come I'd rather he was played in the Zenden role we've never really replaced, inside Stewie.

So that leaves Tayls as first choice for a long hard season. Promising but not the finished article.

All of this makes the Distin signing even more essential to tie up - even if Huth comes on loan. Otherwise we'll have one of the youngest and least experienced back 4s in the Prem. Something akin to the line up that I suffered shipping 7 at Highbury last season. Or we play Ugo who no longer has the legs, whatever his experience.

I notice Das Boat - congratulations on the captaincy - is using the 'transitional season' line too now. I hope none of this refers to a transition to The Championship!!

Interesting that he repeated on Sky today what he said about Gate before he got the manager's job - that he didn't want him to take it because he was our best defender by far and was more use to us there than in the dug-out.

I'd love to say I was confident and optimistic right now but the truth is I'm not and the failures followed by lateness of any success in the transfer market and our reduced quality up front isn't helping.

I have been trying the positive self talk of the sort that Crosby and Coops have been coming out with about Gate recently. But it is no more convincing as I say it than they sounded to me. The very fact we felt obliged to say these things is revealing in itself - a bit like whistling in the dark.

There is a good programme of friendlies coming up and that will tell us a lot. I hope I'm wrong - I am a big Gate fan and really want him to succeed and for us to have a good season.

Off to Florida for hols now and looking for some more encouragement from developments when I return!

Posted by: John Powls  | July 21, 2006 5:21 PM

Chris Gibson wrote...

French Franck has been a good player and yes he's popular with the fans. Good luck to him in his move to the might of Fulham. let us be honest though, at times Franck looked very good but at times very bad.

I must say, I think Arca might be worth a shot. He's been here a while, and has been far and away the Mackems best player for the past couple of years. As for not being a full back, he's played in that position for the past two years. He's still young and understands the cut and thrust of English football. I'd certainly say he'd be worth a shot ahead of the crazy Pogatetz.

The lack of success in the transfer market is alarming. We are now in the pre season programme, the new lads should be bedding in. The transfer market is a difficult place these days and I'm sure Gareth is working overtime. Some of the players we are being linked with are good (Dystin, Huth, Barton, Malbranque) but there must be nothing doing so let's move on.

My starting line up for Reading with the current squad would be Schwarzer, Mcmahon, Taylor, Ehiogu, Riggott, Morrison, Cattermole, Boateng, Downing, Yak and the the Duke.

That team has a decent blend of youth and experience but probably wouldn't finish in the top ten. Maybe though, a run of 10 games and this eleven could grow into a good side.

Posted by: Chris Gibson  | July 23, 2006 10:31 AM

Ian Gill wrote...

Cranky was certainly entertaining and 110% committed.

The reasons why he is leaving may or may not come out and we all have our views. It may be off the pitch activities or the legacy of the Mac dynasty. It doesnt really matter, players have always left clubs. Folk heroes have been replaced by others.

The club has the nucleus of last years squad, older players have moved on, the new kids are coming to the fore. I have said before that this would be a transitional season whether Mac stayed or not.

The difficulty for us is that after a season of wishing for a settled team with the kids featuring we are now faced with putting our faith where our mouths are.

Will Pogo become the established left back? At times last year it was comical to see us penned back around our own area and Pogo still nowhere near his man! 21 players in our half and he was stilling 20 yards from the man he was marking! Take some doing.

But we must remember Cranky was liable to go walkabout in his early days especially before the progression of Downing. Having to be left back and left midfield does stretch a player.

Maybe Pogo will play alongside Riggott and Taylor become the established left back. Will Morisson establish himself on the right?

It will be an interesting season on many fronts, Hansen said you wont win anything with kids only to be proved wrong by Fergie. To be fair his team were a little older than our young tyros. Boat calls for some more experienced players, we have not had much value out of some of ours.

Gate will get the balance right, there is no point bringing in anyone who doesnt improve the team. My guess at the starting 11 is basically the same as Chris Gibson with Ugo replace by Pogo/Huth and Roch in midfield at the expense of Cat or Morisson. Dont be surprised at 4-5-1 away, interesting that the MFC web site report called it 4-5-1 at Gers whilst Gate called it 4-3-3.

Posted by: Ian Gill  | July 24, 2006 10:23 AM

Pinkers wrote...

I must say I find it unbelievable that we are letting one of our best players go to a rival club now he is the finished article, for less than we paid for him when he was just a player with potential.

We've all heard the rumours for the 'real reason' but I had hoped Southgate's appointment would provide an opportunity for a clean wipe of the slate for Franck.

Despite some poor performances last season, (amazing what being hawked around and dropped for a Championship at best player can do for your confidence isn't it?), and while he's obviously not perfect (who is?!), Franck is better defensively in every respect to the other left backs at the club.

In addition he offers a lot going forward with excellent long-range passing, the ability to deliver a quality cross, and a goal threat at set-plays - things that will forever elude Pog.

And that's to say nothing of the fact he has never given less than the cliche of 110% in five years, and the added bonus of being a great ambassador for the club off the pitch doing waaaay more community work than any other player I've seen. Such commitment is very rare these days and the reason why Franck along with a few select others, i.e. Gate and Boat is above criticism for many fans.

I'm sure I'm not alone in being hugely disappointed to see Franck leave especially when he has 2 years left on his deal, to a rival club. It is a massive step backwards, and those who believe Arca can fill the gap are sadly deluded. Arca is a quality player, but he is just not a left back, and he will certainly offer nothing in the air at either end of the pitch - A problem for us already that will be exacerbated by the departure of the best header of the ball we have.
And please don't anyone say Pog can do a job. He's out of his depth.

In short I'm disgusted, this is not progress in any shape or form. Where is the petition Anthony, I want to sign before it's too late.

Viva Franck! A modern Boro legend.

Pinkers

Posted by: Pinkers  | July 24, 2006 1:20 PM

steve parker wrote...

i cannot beleive we are getting rid of franck he is a much better player than pogatetz.he will badly missed

Posted by: steve parker  | July 24, 2006 5:01 PM

Tim wrote...

Well I will give my theory...

I think last season when Boro were up against it and Southgate went round the dressing room having harsh words with several players in order to try and turn things around that some of these guys were not interested.

Frank is a very laid back guy, sometimes overly so and I know he never saw eye to eye with Stevie Mc towards the end, so it wouldnt suprise me if he wasnt up for the fight that Boro hand on their hands.

Now as manager Southgate knows the players who were up for it and those who were ready to sit back and not care about taking the fall. Also having played alongside him for five years I trust his judgement more than the fans.

Posted by: Tim  | July 24, 2006 7:49 PM

Gerry Hughes wrote...

What is the reason for Franc going?

Posted by: Gerry Hughes  | July 25, 2006 5:22 PM

Pinkers wrote...

I can't believe we are letting Franck go on the cheap to a rival club. There are very few better left-backs around and certainly none that we will attract with limited funds and no European football. Arca is a quality player but not a left back, and Pogo stick is a joke. I can't believe he's really a footballer, he seems to have no ability of any kind.

I'm disgusted that MFC have refused to comment over Queudrue - the whole move stinks - there is no financial or football gain for FQ in signing for a small club like Fulham, and it is certainly not good business for us. It is not as if he is out of contract soon either, so why is it happening?

Many Boro fans want to know, because Arca or not, this certainly does not represent progress.

Posted by: Pinkers  | July 26, 2006 2:06 PM

Alex Gill wrote...

It has saddened me over recent seasons to see the Riverside so threadbare. The ground never looks full no matter what the occasion. The outrageous number of matches on Sky surely didn't help that. So this season we have a new manager, hardly any matches on sky and a concentration on the domestic games - so will we see more people with season tickets and a full Riverside? Sadly, I think not.

What a team under a new manager needs is a fresh injection of excitement. Much as I like Southgate, exciting is not an adjective I would use - more reliable or steady. He has suggested that he will play more attacking football, but much of the pre-season so far has been one up front.

He played two up on Saturday, but the midfield at Doncaster consisted of Cattermole, Parlour, Boateng and Taylor - that is three holding players and a left back. Can anyone else see the lack of attacking flair there?

How does this related to Frank? Well, with the promise of attacking and 'flair' football, the fans need to see the right players at the club. Frank was a cult hero at the Riverside and no matter what anyone can say, he gave 110% when most others weren't interested - we sold him. Hasselbaink, basically, his goals turned around our season after Christmas, in Uefa, the Prem and the FA cup - we sold him.

Ok, they perhaps had to go - but what do we bring in to replace these iconic and progressive players? To really fill the stadium and fulfil the promise of attacking football? Julio Arca? Robert Huth, Sylvain Dystain? Necessary maybe but what boro really needs is something exciting. After 5 years under Mac's dross, we do not need simply three defenders, we need a spark.

Forgive my slight pessimism about our chances this season. It may well turn out that Lamb is about to unveil Ronaldinho, but without something to get the town talking the Riverside may often look a lonely place again this season.

Posted by: Alex Gill  | July 31, 2006 9:36 AM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Advertiser