About this blog

Untypical Boro is a lively topical blog by the Evening Gazette's award winning football columnist Anthony Vickers that aims to get behind the headlines to flesh out the stories that Boro fans are talking about.

Incisive, provocative and well informed it seeks to engage with articulate supporters and give them a platform to help set the agenda on the issues that matter.

Recent comments

Recent Posts

Sponsored links

Archives

Links

Advertiser

Sponsored links


Boro 0 Doctors 3

Posted by on July 12, 2006 10:44 AM | 

ROBERT Hoof has failed his medical. The lumbering Chelsea benchwarmer and early-rounds-of-the-Coca-Cola-Cup-specialist is reported to have an on-going dodgy ankle and now the £5m move - "a done deal" inherited from Steve McClaren - has been scrapped.

The modern battery of high-tech medical tests are tough. It is not like the old black and white Ayresome era when doctors said 'cough' and counted then the player did a few shuttle runs and block tackles between slay drags on their fag. Nowadays only the finest physical specimens of athletic excellence pass. And Malcolm Christie.

Now Huth joins an illustrious procession of would-be Boro heroes who failed to make it past the doctors after shaking hands on personal terms and picking out their locker.

In January 2003 Boro snatched a £7m cheque back out of Leeds' hands after seeing the x-rays of Seth Johnson's knee. The shaven headed left-sided run-around-and-kick-people merchant had been identified as an industrious midfield in the Robbie Mustoe mould who could cover for Jonathon Greening's occasional lapses in form.

The deal was done. Leeds were in financial meltdown and couldn't wait to get shot. Johnson was the subject of an widespread apochryphal tale that highlighted the bloated nature of football's stratospheric wages. It was said when he was at Crewe and Leeds approached him he had gone into his meeting determined to ask for £25K but ready to settle for £15k but was left gobsmacked when spendthrift supremo Peter Ridsdale's opening gambit was: "Right, I will give you £37,000 a week and not a penny more." Done! You have been.

Two years later with the bubble burst and Leeds involved in a clearance sale Johnston was Boro-bound on much reduced wages but the security of a four year deal and a big signing on fee. Then came the medical. The word on the Boro 'street' was that the x-ray pictures looked like a jigsaw. Boro naturally pulled the plug and Johnston went back to Leeds where he played about seven games over the next two years before being released.

Boro had kept the impending deal low key. That is the standard practice these days - ever since the red faces at the Riverside over the infamous unveiling of Keith Gillespie. The bookie-bothering Newcastle winger's £3.5m signing had been announced to the local media at the Riverside, out in force for the 'prestigious' pre-season four team JD Sports Cup. Gillespie had actually been paraded around the in a Boro shirt before his would-be new employers squabble over the wooden spoon with the Geordies and signed autographs for smiling kiddies and ra-ras.

Gillespie was due to speak alongside Bryan Robson at a post-match press conference but the gig was hastily cancelled amid rumours that the Norn Iron widemanr had failed the medical, possibly with a torn betting slip. He later joined Blackburn but was no great shakes while Robbo spent the money on Brian Deane instead. Let's hope Southgate's second shot at splashing the Huth cash is more exciting and productive.



Comments (12)

Never Happy wrote...

If the big Italian sides are relegated, there are bound to be a few defenders available. Lets look on the positive side and hope Huth's non signing is a blessing in disguise.
Also Huth's medical failure can not be blamed on Southgate.

Posted by: Never Happy  | July 12, 2006 2:58 PM

Chris Gibson wrote...

ANTONY GARDNER, MATTHEW UPSON, CURTIS DAVIES, ZAK KNIGHT. PROVEN ENGLISH PREMIERSHIP QUALITY AT THE RIGHT AGE. HOWEVER THOSE ITALIANS CAN CERTAINLY DEFEND.

TO A CERTAIN EXTENT IT WORRIES ME THAT DESPITE ALL THE EXPERIENCE GAINED LAST YEAR FOR WHEATER AND BATES. AT WHAT POINT DO WE FIND OUT IF THEY HAVE GOT WHAT IT TAKES? DOES SOMEBODY HAVE TO REACH 21, 22 BEFORE THEY ARE CONSIDERED READY?

I HOPE GARETH IS BRAVE ENOUGH TO GIVE THESE LADS THE CHANCE TO BE REGULARS. SURELY, IN ORDER TO DEVELOP FURTHER THESE LADS NEED GAMES AGAINST HENRYS AND ROONEYS. AS ALAN HANSEN ONCE SAID, WE MIGHT NOT WIN THE LEAGUE WITH KIDS BUT WHO KNOWS WE MIGHT IN 3 YEARS TIME IF WE DEVELOP THESE LADS.

AS FAR AS MEDICALS GO, I AGREE IT'S NOT SOUTHGATES FAULT AND DESPITE HUTHS UNDOUBTED ABILITY, IT'S NOT WORTH THE RISK.

Posted by: Chris Gibson  | July 12, 2006 3:46 PM

John Powls wrote...

True enough, Never Happy, Huth's medical failure can't be blamed on Gate except in one sense - we were prepared to sit around and wait for a medical until after the World Cup, though the rest of the deal had been sorted and Gate relied on a 'gentleman's agreement'.

If we'd pushed to resolve the issue before the World Cup, as we had the time to do, we'd have had the medical that much earlier with more time to sort a replacement.

But he'll live and learn, I guess.

The acid test is now for Gate. Did he have all the eggs in one basket with Huth and has he dropped all the follow up on other central defensive targets? Or has he now got other researched targets still under scrutiny that we can quickly move to and secure without much further delay? If it's the latter then the damage is limited. If it's the former......

For alternatives we should try the Prem first. Difficult to integrate new palyers into the squad anyway without having to acclimatise them to the Prem too, however good they may be.

Posted by: John Powls  | July 12, 2006 3:47 PM

damnYankee wrote...

Anthony, is Oguchi Onyewu still an option?
If I recall correctly you suggested going for Gooch a while back.

Based on things I am reading in the press Southgate has soured on him ? Yet, as recent as last week I think, I also read a quote from Onyewu's agent that Boro's offer was still on the table???

Anythoughts you'd care to share about Gooch, have you soured on him as well ? Is he, in your eyes, a one-man free-kick machine ?

Posted by: damnYankee  | July 12, 2006 5:45 PM

John Powls wrote...

CHRIS - Upson is very long term injured. West Brom want mega millions for Davies who is no better than lads we already have. Knight and Gardner are far from proved. Gardner can't get into Spurs side and when he does he's iffy at best and Knight never covers himself in glory in a shaky Fulham rearguard - his brief sojourn with England was an embarrassment.

Gardner and Knight have the height and some of the physique but neither knows how to use them - curiously, that includes not being that strong in the air. We can do better.

Suggestions now surfacing that the Huth deal may not be off after all and they are awaiting a new set of scans early next week to monitor how the injury is healing. That's supposedly why no official statement from either club, the palyer or his rep.

Posted by: John Powls  | July 13, 2006 9:03 AM

Ian Gill wrote...

Is it time for the young guns to step up to the plate? Cloughie always said if they are good enough they are old enough.

A well organised team, playing in an established pattern, with round pegs in round holes will always do well. The constant 'cleverness' of our previous 'clever' coach did not allow for continuity.

Oddly last season was the worst of his five for that. It was not helped by the number of matches. We will play 15-20 less matches this season, with the squad we have we may struggle to keep everyone onside.

Unless there is major pruning it will be pointless bringing in anyone unless they are better than we have already. Not getting Huth was a blow but Bates, Wheater, Davies are Boro lads gagging to play alongside Riggott. We have Cranky and Pogo who will both want to play. McMahon and Parnaby will be jostling for right back.

Right side midfield may be a problem but there will be a kid desperate to challenge Morrison, will Roch move over to accomodate the Cat alongside Boat? Where does our new French lad fit in? Downing being pushed by Johnson. Yak and Veruka up front with Mass, Christie and Graham.

Then we have our 'mature' assets in Mendi, Ugo and Parlour. And there will be more kids forcing their way into the reckoning.

Yes, there are areas we can improve but at what cost and will they come. We all argued Mac didnt get the best out of the squad for whatever reason. The season turned round last year when the players stood up to be counted.

It is substantially the same but with more experience in the younger elements. This may be a season of consolidation but if we have to give the kids the chance to become the future so be it. If a couple of new faces come in how long will they take to settle? That could lead us to look at premiership players or accept the teething problems associated with overseas players.

Whatever, it is early days with the world cup just finished, as said elsewhere who knows what will happen with the Italian sides. It only takes half a dozen top players to come onto the market and there will be a chain reaction down the pyramid. A settled squad in pre season is perfect but like many we will have to make do with what we can get.

Posted by: Ian Gill  | July 13, 2006 9:44 AM

Steve Burke wrote...

Sol Campbell is a more than able and proven defender, as well as mutual respect for each other (Southgate) im sure he would bring in experience which would see the younger lads like Bates and Wheater gain an invaluable amount of experience to carry on when he retires in a year or two.

Maybe a bit of Redcar sea air and Guisborough hills greenery would sort out his head for those of you that thinks he is still a nutcase!!!

Posted by: Steve Burke  | July 13, 2006 11:43 AM

Never Happy wrote...

Steve Burke, Sol Campbell is past his sell by date and if reports are correct wants 80k a week. Hopefully Boro will never be a pension scheme for this type of player again.

If Southgate is going to allow Boro to play more attacking football why not go for a 3 - 5 - 2 formation with Riggott, Franq and one of the younger defender's playing at the back.

I think this formation will work well, especially at home when away sides often only play with one front man.

Posted by: Never Happy  | July 13, 2006 1:04 PM

J wrote...

Actually Seth Johnson signed for Leeds from Derby (he was at Crewe before Jim Smith signed him for the Rams), and the fee that Middlesbrough agreed was more in the region of £3M not £7M, the price O'Leary paid Derby County for his services.

Posted by: J  | July 14, 2006 3:44 PM

Pete wrote...

Thank goodness we found out before we splashed out , the last thing we needed was a big priced player being a sicky. We've had enough of them in our recent past. Gareth must know plenty of players in his own position / mould, but that Yank didn't look the part at the World Cup.

Posted by: Pete  | July 15, 2006 10:31 AM

Gaz wrote...

"Actually," Never Happy, check your facts before posting. Seth Johnson signed for Leeds for 7 million.

Posted by: Gaz  | July 24, 2006 4:58 AM

J wrote...

That's what I said Gaz, but you chose to ignore it. Shall we spell it out for you Gaz:

Seth Johnson
Crewe to Derby.....£3M
Derby to Leeds.....£7M
Proposed moved to Middlesbrough...£3M was the mooted fee.

"Check your facts." Why don't you read the words Gaz?

Posted by: J  | August 5, 2006 12:55 AM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Advertiser